Tales from the arXiv: Categories are just like animals

Here is a new abstract that just showed up on the arXiv:

arXiv:0808.1032
Date: Thu, 7 Aug 2008 14:15:28 GMT (2695kb)

Title: Introducing categories to the practicing physicist
Authors: Bob Coecke
Categories: quant-ph math-ph math.CT math.MP
Comments: 30 pages and 19 pictures
Journal-ref: What is category theory? Advanced Studies in Mathematics and
Logic, volume 30, pages 45-74, Polimetrica Publishing, 2006
\\
We argue that category theory should become a part of the daily practice of
the physicist, and more specific, the quantum physicist and/or informatician.
The reason for this is not that category theory is a better way of doing
mathematics, but that monoidal categories constitute the actual algebra of
practicing physics. We will not provide rigorous definitions or anything
resembling a coherent mathematical theory, but we will take the reader for a
journey introducing concepts which are part of category theory in a manner that
the physicist will recognize them.
\\ ( http://arxiv.org/abs/0808.1032 , 2695kb)


The reason I am including this entry is that it reminds me of a certain incident in the graduate abstract algebra course I took at Cornell. The professor was introducing the idea of 'category' and decided he wanted to do it without a precise definition. None of us were really following him, so we asked him kindly if he'd give him a definition and he said something along the lines of 'You're going to learn what a category is the way you learned what an animal is: by seeing examples of them.' He then gave another one or two non-illuminating (at least without the definition) examples to us, at which point a brave student (not me) asked him "What is a category?" The professor went slightly ballistic at that question given the prior exchange.

To this day, all I remember about categories is that they're important in abstract algebra and that they're apparently like animals. (I suppose if I tried reading the above article, I could fix that, but I don't really care enough to do so.) That was one of my more memorable classroom experiences.