Here is a useful article about mistakes reviewers make and things to think about when one writes a referee report on a paper. It's good for both junior and senior people, and reminders even for senior people (myself very much included) is definitely a good thing. (It's views on how much one should stress the details versus the big picture of a paper do, however, appear to be different from mine. I didn't look at that part carefully but focused on the headline points rather than on the details therein --- possibly ironically.)
(Tip of the cap to Vinko Zlatić and Bruno Gonçalves.)
3 days ago
No comments:
Post a Comment